PostAndRape

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 28 May 2013

Are Religions Inherently Sexist?

Posted on 17:30 by Unknown

I listened to this interesting interview where Katha Pollitt addresses the question whether religions are inherently sexist.  She concludes that they don't have to be, if we only could somehow dispense with the assumption that the ancient holy texts have nothing to do with the patriarchal tribal societies of that era.  If sexism is seen as a command from a god, well, then a religion arguing that IS inherently sexist.

To turn one of the old Abrahamic religions into a nonsexist one is very hard work,  however, and Judaism, Christianity (and different groups among Christianity) and Islam are at different stages of that process.

An essential requirement is to read religious texts with the understanding that they were written by human beings (who interpreted their beliefs of what a divine power wanted) and addressed to other human beings of the era who lived in utterly patriarchal societies.  The more concrete and literal the mainstream religious interpretation of a holy text now is, the more unpleasant that religion will be for its female believers.

What is needed is a deep reading of a particular concrete text, a reading which looks at what that text meant at a particular time and in a particular place.   Literalists and those who believe, for instance, that the Bible or the Koran is the inerrant and eternal world of a god will not agree with that.

But to do otherwise truly confuses the issue.  Take, for an example, the rule the Taliban enforced during its reign in Afghanistan:  That women's shoes should not make a noise, because a man must not hear a woman's footsteps.  Here's one step deeper into the question:

Jewelry must not be displayed, and it is especially important that it does not make noise as a woman walks (an ankle-bracelet with bells, for example). Women in pre-Islamic Arabia used to wear such bracelets and stamp their feet in the markets in order to entice and attract men.
The Bible refers to those ankle bracelets, too. 

Did all women wear bells around their ankles in the days of Muhammad?  I doubt it, though perhaps they did.  Still, my Google searches suggest that ankle bells were used by dancers and still are so used.

There is also a connection with ankle bells and prostitution, whether forced or voluntary.

My tentative theory is that the focus on women making a noise (by having heels in their shoes, say) has to do with these associations with dancing girls and possible prostitution.  In short, the deeper meaning has nothing to do with whether men can hear women's footsteps but with the meaning of ankle bells at the time of Mohammed and at the time of the men who wrote the Bible. 

Literal and concrete readings of the various holy texts tend to give us odd and mistaken rules, and it would be helpful if such rules were addressed inside the various religions by those who reject the most concrete readings.  In any case, what a concrete reading might have been a thousand years ago is impossible to ascertain.

I agree with Katha that religions don't have to be sexist.  But  I don't think the traditional patriarchal religions give up the battle very easily, and the battle lines are drawn most unfairly. 

Those who attempt to influence the sexist messages of religions can be accused of fighting a god, whereas those who defend an ancient interpretation of what that god might wish us to do can simply state, categorically, that the interpretation IS divinely decreed and never will change.  The basic question all this hinges on cannot be determined by purely intellectual arguments or by empirical evidence, though sometimes showing how other parts of the text have been abandoned can help. 

But the game is rigged, from the beginning.






Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Yellen vs. Summers As A Metaphor
    Atrios posted on the nomination of the next chief of Federal Reserve.  The forerunners have been defined as Lawrence Summers and Janet Yelle...
  • The New Pope
    Is Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio, the former archbishop of Buenos Aires, who takes the name Pope Francis.  He is the first non-European Pop...
  • Speed Blogging, Mon 9/16/2013: On Women
    Note:  Not all these are from the last few days. First , the Taliban in Afghanistan is waging a physical war against women in the public sec...
  • Those Discouraged Young Men Who Live in Their Parents' Basement
    Something interesting from Pew Research on the possibility that young men are now so discouraged and effeminate because of feminism that the...
  • Do Not Be Afraid Of Life. Echidne's Poetry Hour.
    A musical adaptation of Kaarlo Sarkia 's poem: A rough translation of the lyrics (by me and without the rhyme): Do not be afraid of lif...
  • Never Thin Enough? Thoughts About What We Can Sell in the Labor Market.
    Content Warning:  Body Images and Anorexia Joan Smith in the UK Independent reviews The Vogue Factor , a book about the eating requirements...
  • More Bad News From India
    Content note:  Sexual violence The victim of the Delhi gang rape is extremely ill at a Singapore hospital where she was airlifted a few day...
  • While You Wait For The Results
    In the US federal elections,  you can watch this slide show of  American women voting in earlier elections (via Hecate ).    I assume that...
  • If I Close The Tap Will Water Stop Running? The Texas Birth Control Experiment.
    A peculiar thing happened in Texas!  Its lawmakers decided to do away with funding Planned Parenthood for political forced-birth reasons, ev...
  • Polling Conspiracies
    I once wrote a bad poem about Conspiracy Theories.  It began like this: There are five fat men in a secret  cave somewhere. They are naked. ...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (365)
    • ►  September (20)
    • ►  August (34)
    • ►  July (35)
    • ►  June (44)
    • ▼  May (69)
      • Fun With Economics: The Politics of The Gender Ga...
      • Why Lou Dobbs Is Sad About Employed Moms
      • Good News Friday: The NYT Editorial on Facebook A...
      • More on the Demonization of Employed Mothers at Fox
      • Today's Musical Interlude
      • Four Men On Fox Explain Why More Breadwinning Moms...
      • Meanwhile, in El Salvador, A Woman's LIfe/Health ...
      • Today's Science Granola. With Strawberries.
      • Good News: Facebook Will Consider Changes To Its ...
      • Breadwinner Moms!
      • Are Religions Inherently Sexist?
      • Tamara Karsavina - 'La Danse du flambeau' (1909)
      • On Memorial Day
      • Real Education. Fear it!
      • Three Old Men Define Women's Proper Roles
      • Saturday Musical Interlude
      • Top National Security Journalists
      • Ouch! It Really Did Hurt. Who Would Have Thought?
      • A Good News Friday Dump From A Gallup Survey
      • On the Ideas of Forced-Birthers
      • From The I've-Been-Doing-This-For-Years Archives
      • The Austerians vs. Anti-Austerians: The Saga Cont...
      • The Facebook Campaign
      • Meanwhile*, in Afghanistan
      • Reading For Today
      • Remember Girls Gone Wild?
      • The Floating Dream
      • Thank You And More Procrastination
      • Cheating the Government
      • The Oklahoma Twister
      • Good News
      • Read This Article: A Word From Our Sponsor.
      • Funniest Quote of the Day
      • For Alas, We Have Sinned. On Michael KInsley's De...
      • Procrastination
      • 115 Pounds of Pure Grit
      • Thanks, Merci, Spasiba, Danke, Tack, Kiitos etc.
      • The Stoopid, It Burns
      • Human Parthenogenesis. That's how Sluts Get Pregn...
      • Last Day of The Famous 2013 Fund Drive
      • On Angelina Jolie's Courage And The Movie Industry
      • Today's Echidne-the-Political-Economist Thought
      • Diversity on Evening Cable News
      • My Future As A Bag Lady
      • Guns
      • The Ant-Assassination. Or on Fund-Raising.
      • Why Health Care Markets Are Not Competitive
      • Play in Your Own League, Journalists
      • Interesting Stuff For Friday: Oppressed Men, Zomb...
      • The Second Day of My Fund Drive
      • Speaking Of Educational Statistics. The Stories G...
      • Violence By Women, Finnish Style
      • More on the Capitalists' Flexibility Act of 2013
      • Pope Francis to Nuns: Be Mothers, Not Old Maids!
      • Time To Pay The Piper
      • When Corpses Are Buried Or Unearthed
      • Today's Interesting Reads. Or My Posts If I Made ...
      • On Sugar Daddies And Cougars
      • Today's Surrealistic News
      • Today's Gun News
      • Today's Puzzle About a Piece of News: Are These N...
      • Opinions about Gender in the Pew Report on World's...
      • On Suicide Statistics
      • Things I Will Never Understand* About The Gun Culture
      • Today's Quote About The Young
      • Dead As A Doornail. Feminism is.
      • The Need For Better Science Popularizations
      • The Chest Hair Problem
      • Stuff To Read on Gender, With Some Echidne Analysis
    • ►  April (39)
    • ►  March (39)
    • ►  February (41)
    • ►  January (44)
  • ►  2012 (135)
    • ►  December (41)
    • ►  November (37)
    • ►  October (54)
    • ►  September (3)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile