PostAndRape

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, 6 June 2013

Only in Texas?

Posted on 12:35 by Unknown

The Google doesn't have a lot about this story, so you may wish to take that into account in judging it.  But the outline is this:

In 2009 a man, Ezekiel Gilbert,  contacts a woman working as an escort, Lenora Ivie Frago,  via Craigslist,  and gives her $150, in expectation of sexual services which are not forthcoming.  Rather, the escort leaves the man's house with the money.

He shoots her, paralyzing her. Ms Frago  dies several months later from the consequences of the shooting.   The case goes to court, and the jury acquits the man in her shooting death:

The verdict came after almost 11 hours of deliberations that stretched over two days. The trial began May 17 but had a long hiatus after a juror unexpectedly had to leave town for a funeral.
During closing arguments Tuesday, Gilbert's defense team conceded the shooting did occur but said the intent wasn't to kill. Gilbert's actions were justified, they argued, because he was trying to retrieve stolen property: the $150 he paid Frago. It became theft when she refused to have sex with him or give the money back, they said.
Gilbert testified earlier Tuesday that he had found Frago's escort ad on Craigslist and believed sex was included in her $150 fee. But instead, Frago walked around his apartment and after about 20 minutes left, saying she had to give the money to her driver, he said.
That driver, the defense contended, was Frago's pimp and her partner in the theft scheme.
The Texas law that allows people to use deadly force to recover property during a nighttime theft was put in place for “law-abiding” citizens, prosecutors Matt Lovell and Jessica Schulze countered. It's not intended for someone trying to force another person into an illegal act such as prostitution, they argued.

Can this really be true?  If it is, why is a transaction that is illegal in Texas (selling sex) given this type of property rights protection?  If I hired someone to kill another person in Texas, and the hired killer ran off with my money without doing the agreed-upon murder, could I then kill him or her and not get punished for it at all?  Or is it the case that Mr Gilbert will get a separate punishment for being a john?  Is that even illegal in Texas?  (I'm too lazy to research it.)

Then there's the sum of money which is deemed adequate to cause someone's death, 150 dollars.  Is that the worth of a life?

The story is hard to believe.  I'm also concerned about the jury thinking that being an escort automatically means selling sexual services, when that is not written down anywhere at all.  My concern is because similar one-sided interpretations could spread to all sorts of exchanges, and juries appear to be ready to favor the "buyer's" interpretation here.

Let's flip this over.  Suppose that Ms Frago had had sex with Mr Gilbert and Mr Gilbert then refused to pay her.  Would she have been within her rights in Texas if she had then killed Mr Gilbert?  As far as I can tell, that should be the case.  But I very much doubt the jury would have acquitted her.
----
Via Gawker 


Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Yellen vs. Summers As A Metaphor
    Atrios posted on the nomination of the next chief of Federal Reserve.  The forerunners have been defined as Lawrence Summers and Janet Yelle...
  • The New Pope
    Is Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio, the former archbishop of Buenos Aires, who takes the name Pope Francis.  He is the first non-European Pop...
  • Speed Blogging, Mon 9/16/2013: On Women
    Note:  Not all these are from the last few days. First , the Taliban in Afghanistan is waging a physical war against women in the public sec...
  • More Bad News From India
    Content note:  Sexual violence The victim of the Delhi gang rape is extremely ill at a Singapore hospital where she was airlifted a few day...
  • If I Close The Tap Will Water Stop Running? The Texas Birth Control Experiment.
    A peculiar thing happened in Texas!  Its lawmakers decided to do away with funding Planned Parenthood for political forced-birth reasons, ev...
  • Those Discouraged Young Men Who Live in Their Parents' Basement
    Something interesting from Pew Research on the possibility that young men are now so discouraged and effeminate because of feminism that the...
  • Do Not Be Afraid Of Life. Echidne's Poetry Hour.
    A musical adaptation of Kaarlo Sarkia 's poem: A rough translation of the lyrics (by me and without the rhyme): Do not be afraid of lif...
  • Polling Conspiracies
    I once wrote a bad poem about Conspiracy Theories.  It began like this: There are five fat men in a secret  cave somewhere. They are naked. ...
  • Never Thin Enough? Thoughts About What We Can Sell in the Labor Market.
    Content Warning:  Body Images and Anorexia Joan Smith in the UK Independent reviews The Vogue Factor , a book about the eating requirements...
  • While You Wait For The Results
    In the US federal elections,  you can watch this slide show of  American women voting in earlier elections (via Hecate ).    I assume that...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (365)
    • ►  September (20)
    • ►  August (34)
    • ►  July (35)
    • ▼  June (44)
      • Today's Saying
      • The Wussification of American Men. Eric Bolling o...
      • Speed-Blogging, June 27, 2013
      • Rick Perry, For the Egg-Americans
      • On Twitter
      • Working Women. Think Again!
      • Good News Wednesday
      • And The Supremes Sing, But Not of Gerrymandering o...
      • The Great Texas Filibuster
      • I Told You Being Ridiculous About Reproductive Rig...
      • Lou Dobbs With A Blackboard: On Oppressed Men
      • Garden Blogging
      • Speed-Blogging, June 21, 2013: On Wisconsin Unemp...
      • Catching Women. A Guide For Trappers and Hunters.
      • Phil Gingrey on Gender Roles in Marriage
      • Meet James Taranto
      • On the Skill Gap: Aren't US Workers Good Enough?
      • More on HR 1797: Ban Abortions After 20 Weeks
      • It's OK To Be Ridiculous About Women's Reproductiv...
      • Speed-Blogging, 6/17/2013: On Us Involvement in Sy...
      • Blog Stuff
      • Men Caused The Menopause. Today's Funny Research.
      • Things Which Can Get You Fired: Beauty and Being ...
      • On Forced Fatherhood
      • The Man-Brain in Maine
      • David Brooks: The Ties That Bind....And Chafe
      • Speed-Blogging, June 12, 2013: On Market Informati...
      • The Slut-Or-Madonna Culture: Who Is The Goalkeeper?
      • Meet E.W.Jackson, the Republican nominee for Lieut...
      • And a Joke
      • Good News on Gender Issues
      • Why I Don't Write About the NSA And Other Importan...
      • Men in Skirts
      • And Yet More on The Ezekiel Gilbert Case in Texas
      • You're Doing it Rong. John Pilger Explains What F...
      • More on Ezekiel Gilbert And The Right To Use A Wea...
      • Fox And The War on Women
      • Only in Texas?
      • Stuff To Read, June 5, 2013
      • On Sexual Assaults in the US Military
      • Get Lucky at 35 000 feet
      • Speed Blogging: On Suicides Among Baby Boomers, O...
      • Today's Evolutionary Psychology Post
      • The Challenge: Prove that Gender Discrimination i...
    • ►  May (69)
    • ►  April (39)
    • ►  March (39)
    • ►  February (41)
    • ►  January (44)
  • ►  2012 (135)
    • ►  December (41)
    • ►  November (37)
    • ►  October (54)
    • ►  September (3)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile